Sunday, 18 March 2012
-
Rachael Ray Doesn't Write Her Cookbooks
I came across a very interesting article in the New York Times today. It turns out many of my favorite cookbook authors don’t actually write their own cookbooks! They hire food ghostwriters to write everything from recipes to content to the introduction.
Julia Moskin writes about her experience and the world of cookbook ghostwriting in her March 13th article “I Was a Cookbook Ghostwriter”. She admits that, although she thought it was a dream job, it also held many humiliations. As a cookbook ghostwriter you have to put your ego aside and do what the chef wants you to do. She mentions horror stories of chefs ripping up ideas, demanding the writer to start over. The cookbook ghostwriter is, in essence, dating the chef, with the end result hopefully being a cookbook that captures the vision of the chef. Some ghostwriters are credited, but many are not. J.J. Goode is April Bloomfield’s ghostwriter for A Girl and Her Pig.
I admit to being a little bit sad and slightly disappointed by this finding, but I can understand why chefs do it. They are chefs after all, not writers. Bobby Flay admits to this; “I consider myself an ‘author,’ in quotes, but not a writer,” Mr. Flay said. “I have skills in the kitchen, but the writers keep the project on track, meet the deadlines, make the editor happy.” Other chefs known to hire cookbook ghostwriters are Rachael Ray, Martha Stewart, Jamie Oliver, and Gwyneth Paltrow.

I have always had that lingering thought in the back of my mind of how these chefs, who are probably very busy cooking, managing restaurants, and filming episodes of television shows, manage to write so many cookbooks. Well, the answer to that question is, they don’t. I am surprised the idea of these chefs hiring writers never crossed my mind, but now that I know, it sounds like a cool gig. I am not sure I would be into doing it, but it certainly opened up my eyes to the different types of careers related to food out there.
After my split second of disappointment upon reading this article, I realized that it is best to leave the cooking to the chefs and the writing to the writers. I do not think there is anything wrong with hiring ghostwriters, but it would be nice if they were all credited. Writing a book can’t be easy!
What are your thoughts on cookbook ghostwriting?
Post a Comment
- Back to ireallylikefood's IReallyLikeFood Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in ireallylikefood's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (15)
I agree, chefs are chefs but not necessarily writers. However, I also agree, if a chef has a ghostwriter, he or she should be credited. They still contributed. In movies, at the end, they list the actor's personal assistant(s) but they do not appear, but still are an integral part of the actor's success, why shouldn't the person putting the words together for a chef be credited?
I think that's fine, as long as they know their recipes well. Not everyone a great writer. For busy chefs, they need all help they could get to bring their recipes to your kitchen and table.
It doesn't surprise me, Rachel Ray didn't start out as a chef.
If you agree to do it, you're agreeing to the consequences.
Cookbook ghostwriting? Man... I thought most of the chefs would write their own book and recipes, but than again its understandable that the chefs have pretty busy lives from running a restaurant or restaurants, to filming television shows, joining competitions, and etc. It's a crazy life. I guess it's fine, as long as what's written is being true to the words and honest. I hope Julia Child wrote her own words and cookbooks.
wow that makes alot of sense...
i always wondered how they could write up so many recipes in a thick cookbook!
i completely understand that they wouldn't write their own cookbooks, but they should always give credit where credit is due.
@TheFashionableEconomist@xanga - Me too!
@goodeatings - Gosh, I hope so.
Gwyneth Paltrow, a chef? Since when, and why would anyone pay money for something she has supposedly written?
@chickensrule4ever@xanga - You should have seen the uproar that was caused by the first issue of Bon Appetit Magazine to feature a human on the cover. Darn that new Editor in Chief. Ms. Paltrow is not a chef, she's a home cook/food blogger who was afforded an opportunity to write a cookbook.
My friend took a cooking class at Duke with a woman who actually worked with Rachel Ray. She said that Rachel was more of a business person than a chef so I'm not too surprised that she has a ghost writer. I still like watching her show though!
So? Even presidents don't write their speeches.
yeah, well I agree they should get credited.
but then again the cookbooks I have are all like this: picture on one page, ingredients and instructions on the next. That's not that hard.
And nearly all "stars" actually have a whole team behind them.