Thursday, 10 June 2010
-
Chocolate Cake. With Mayonnaise??

Tomorrow is my boyfriend's 20th birthday (he's growing up so fast), and I decided as his lovely girlfriend that I would whip him up a cake. Personally I am a fan of everything vanilla. Vanilla ice cream (more specifically vanilla bean--that bean just adds some extra spunk), vanilla extract, vanilla, vanilla, vanilla. But Joey (that's my boyfriend) likes chocolate, so I had to be selfless and make a chocolate cake.
Not that chocolate is an unpleasant flavor, I just happen to prefer vanilla. Chocolate and vanilla lovers are at a crossroad and most people prefer one (even if it's by a small margin) over the other. So chocolate it is. I looked around for a recipe on Epicurious.com (A bible for cooking. I personally prefer it over foodnetwork.com....so skip on over, brethren) and I found one that looked pretty good, but it had a surprising ingredient. Mayonnaise. Yes, you heard me correctly. Mayo-stinkin-nnaise.
Personally I would rather hurl myself off of a moderately tall surface than eat mayonnaise (that might be a slight exaggeration). Whenever my friend Kara and I come across the mayonnaise at the condiments section of our college cafeteria, we shudder in fear and run away in tears (also a slight exaggeration. Dramatization, my friends, is the key to weaving a good story). But I heard that putting mayonnaise in a cake instead of oil actually makes it really moist, and of course you can't taste the vile stuff once it's cooked into the cake. So I proceeded.
Ingredients
She was just handed a mayonnaise sandwich. What to do?!Cake:
- 2 ounces bittersweet chocolate (do not exceed 61% cacao), chopped
- 2/3 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
- 1 3/4 cups boiling water
- 2 3/4 cups all purpose flour
- 1 1/4 teaspoons baking soda
- 1/4 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 cup (packed) dark brown sugar
- 1 1/3 cups mayonnaise (do not use reduced-fat or fat-free)
- 2 large eggs
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
So off I went on an adventure with mayonnaise and chocolate. For this cake you are required to make three main mixtures for the batter. A chocolate mixture, a flower mixture and a mayonnaise mixture. The chocolate mixture was easy; simply boil water and mix it in with the chopped chocolate and the cocoa powder. Mix that stuff up and there you go, a beautiful chocolate soup looking thing. So I was sitting there with a vat of hot chocolate in front of me (tempting) but I had to be strong and proceed.
The next mixture is even easier, just combine the flour, baking powder and baking soda. Done. Well you have to sift it in which is sort of annoying, but it's not that bad. Then the accursed mayonnaise mixture which you make by combining the brown and white sugars and the mayonnaise.
Listen here folks, do you know how tempting it is to see a sugary mixture in front of you with this substance that looks sort of like butter and not be able to eat it? Well let me supply you with a firsthand account, it's quite challenging. The only thing that kept me from sticking a spoon in that stuff was the reoccurring thought of that glopy, thick, foul mayonnaise cursing the sugar.
Ruined by mayonnaise. Curses.
So then once you finish that you alternate putting the flour mixture and the chocolate mixture into the mayonnaise mixture, using an electric beater each time to marry all of the flavors together. And I'll admit, it was certainly a ceremony. The batter was thick and rich looking and smelled divine. Try and stay strong, it will be difficult to not want to eat some right out of the bowl.
Also, before you pour your batter into the pans, remember to grease them up. I (sadly to say) am a moron, and forgot to grease my pans, promptly remembering as soon as the first one was dripping with batter. So thinking quickly and poured it back into the bowl and washed it out. I'm so crafty.

Don't forget the Pam, kiddies.
Once everything was all greased up I slapped those babies into the oven for 30 minutes. After which they came out looking delightful, toothpick clean and all. Now for the frosting.
Frosting:
- 10 ounces bittersweet chocolate (do not exceed 61% cacao), chopped
- 1 1/2 cups (3 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 3 cups powdered sugar
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
Time to double boil some chocolate, chickadees. Unfortunately my mom just microwaved some low fat popcorn, so now the chocolatey delicious smell of cake has been masked by low fat corn. Uncool. Double boiling chocolate is wonderful, I just love watching it melt. And you will too, no doubt.
Making frosting is actually a lot easier than I thought. All you do is mix butter, chocolate and sugar (add a few more ingredients) and there's your frosting. Then you frost up your cake, friends! Here's a tip, there will be a LOT of frosting, so put more frosting on the layers than you think you should or else you will wind up with a ton of frosting on the outside of the cake. Which is fine, if you want it that way, that's just something I'll do differently for next time.
There is something so comforting about homemade frosting. It's so sweet and thick and rich and delicious. It deserves recognition for not coming in a can. In fact I have decided that after today's events I can never use canned frosting again. It just isn't the same.

Boo.
Yay! (Just imagine it's chocolate)
Another tip, put wax paper on your cake plate before you start stacking your cakes because when you pull off the wax paper it will leave a clean plate. Honestly, the picture looks neater than my cake, but I think that's what gives mine some personality. Yeah, it's a little lumpy and it leans over, but it's mine.
Here's the end result! Mine doesn't look quite as neat, I wanted to show you all but the photo uploader wasn't working! If it starts working again I'll upload it.
http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/Chocolate-Mayonnaise-Cake-358241
Here's the recipe if you are interested in making the cake.Are there any foods that you have put peculiar ingredients in? Like mayonnaise in a chocolate cake, for instance. What are your favorite cake recipes? Or even frosting recipes?
Post a Comment
- Back to ireallylikefood's IReallyLikeFood Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in ireallylikefood's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (64)
That's more like a recipe for making your ass go from (__)(__) to (______)(_______)
This actually originated in WWII. Women used to use mayonnaise for baking instead of eggs because eggs were needed for the war effort, so many women gave them up.
Why in the heck do people even care about a chocolate cake with mayonaise, how is this even a worthy blog? I just wasted 10 minutes of my life.
Hope your boyfriend likes it. No need to tell him the ingredients. haha
You can also substitute oil/mayo in cakes with sour cream or plain/vanilla yogurt. I usually use yogurt, since that's the only "gloppy" substance that doesn't make me gag.
@Paul_Partisan@xanga - bahahahahaha
You can use applesauce instead of oil too if you're trying to watch calories.
I actually think the mayonnaise is in the recipe to replace butter. Most cake recipes uses butter for the fatty substance. Some people can't eat dairy so they use mayonnaise. I like how some people are suggesting using other liquids to replace the mayonnaise/butter/oil in a cake recipe. Personally I use butter or oil, depending on what the recipe calls for. The fat gives the cake flavor and keeps it moist. If I am really that concerned about my fat intake, I am probably better off not eating cake and choose fruit instead. (Or make angel food cake.) But, I have been challenged by a coworker to try making chocolate cake with mayonnaise, so I might try it soon. Hope your boyfriend likes the cake!
@Thatslifekid@xanga - If you knew you weren't going to care about it then why did you read it.....? And if you saw that you weren't interested in it as you continued to read it then why did you keep reading it? You're making yourself sound pretty unintelligent by making comments like that when you had plenty of time to stop reading it if you weren't interested.
@Paul_Partisan@xanga - LOLOL, have I mentioned lately that you make me giggle?
I have had chocolate cake made with mayo and I think it's better than the regular chocolate cake. My grandma has made it that way for as long as I can remember.
@Thatslifekid@xanga - why would you comment about how you wasted your time? way to go dick..
I can't eat mayonnaise...so I don't know if I could eat this...but it sounds like something they would like in Japan! They use mayonnaise in everything! Even on top of their pizza!
You didn't answer the most important question -- how did your boyfriend like it?
Mayonaise? I'll try anything once but I might be grossed out.
@chocolatescifi@xanga - He really liked it, which I was happy about!
@WhenHateIsTheOnlyOption@xanga - Yeah, trust me I absolutely HATE mayonnaise and I was sort of freaked out to put it in a chocolate cake, but when you eat it you can't taste any mayonnaise which was a relief, haha.
@Thatslifekid@xanga - I liked it. It was clever and had substance, as opposed to the typical "Here's-the-recipe-hope-you-enjoy-it-do-you-like-this-type-of-food" shebang.
@imyourstargirl@xanga - Thank you :) I really appreciate it
Anyone here ever hear of portillos?
It's a restaurant/drive thru in chicago
and their famous chocolate cake is also made with mayo
So what's in Mayonnaise???? Oil and Egg. And look on the back of every cake mix box, what do you need? Eggs, oil, water.
Duhhhhhhh.
@PrincessPatriotII@xanga - I just happened to find that it tasted smoother than cake mix. Maybe it was because the mayonnaise was already a mixed substance rather than adding eggs and oil and not making a mayonnaise mixture when mixed.
@callanmathis - I just meant that I find it funny that everyone is grossed out by the whole mayo thing even though there's mayonnaise ingredients in all cakes.
Glad your cake turned out well. I like chocolate, but like you I also prefer vanilla over chocolate.
mayo is freakin nasty i don't even get why people eat that crap
So what did it taste like? At the end of the post I was dying to know!! Because I also detest mayo, yucky, yuck! The thought of it makes me shudder.